An intellectual argument.

I have a failing.

If I like a video enough, especially if it’s a video about science or technology, I can’t help but read a few of the peanut gallery responses to the video.

That last video I posted up… you know, the one from TED? yeah, I read some responses.

Like this one.

Mar 16 2009: If you look at the progression of the human race in the last 100 years, with every major advancement in technology, it seems to be accompanied with even greater stories of crime, paedophilia, drug misuse, man-made disasters, and climate change. I’m not saying that technology is bad — far from it — but major advancements need to be watched carefully because the misuse of power can wreck people’s lives, even disrupt entire nations!

If you could biologically enhance yourself or reconfigure your genome, imagine how people might misuse such power? It is a sad fact that most people are naturally selfish, motivated by their own lusts.

Since I disagree wholeheartedly with his statement,Ā  for obvious and logical reasons, I *sigh* created an account and posted up a reply.

And since the reply was lengthy, and I sweated a little over my phraseology, I figured I’d share it wit’ youse guys, since I’m basically lazy/morally bankrupt. ^^

My response:

“Less than 5 minutes ago:

I’d like to see your statistics for those statements about crime. From what I can remember of my history and sociology classes, crime rates are (and have been for the last hundred years or so) on a comparative downswing, with an illusory upswing as crime detection technology improves. For example, while pedophilia was certainly just as rampant in Victorian England as today, there were comparatively few trials, and very little public acknowledgment that such things were even possible.
In other words, the reason we see so much more crime is because we catch it much more effectively now than a hundred years ago.
Of course I could be wrong. However, whether or not crime is on an upswing, it’s extremely unlikely technology has anything to do with it.
As any economics student can tell you, drawing a causal link between two isolated data sets borders on hubris if done without strong outside evidence.”

Advertisements

7 thoughts on “An intellectual argument.

  1. Otherwise known as “correlation does not prove causation.” šŸ˜‰ You’re so smart. I wouldn’t have even thought twice about that comment and just accepted it as most likely true.

    And then gone and cruised for porn.

    In all seriousness, thanks for reminding me to be critical.

    Like

      1. I lied. šŸ˜¦ I’m actually terrified of most porn, except the really vanilla stuff. It makes me feel all squirmy and uncomfortable.

        Like

      2. You know, I don’t much go in for porn myself. Most porn just doesn’t do it for me at this point. It’s more boredom on my end, though. There’s no emotional attachment, you can’t touch the actors, and they wouldn’t want to touch you (lol), and it’s pretty much fake. So much better to get it on with a flesh and blood boyfriend or girlfriend, if you have the option, or use your theatre of the mind, if the other isn’t available.

        Like

      3. And I SOO blame you, Badger, for making this comments section about porn instead of intellectual awesomeness. lol. Miss Hep made a throw away comment. You’re the one turned it into a full-on discussion.

        I hate you so much. \(>o<)/
        As compared with Miss Hep awesomeness. Who rocks. YAY! (^.~) (^v^)

        Like

      4. Miss Hep… that is so adorable, I may have to steal it. But anyway, I really was trying to point out that, though I try not to be, I sometimes am intellectually lazy when I’m fartin’ around on the internets. It helps me to remember to be skeptical when I see intelligent people make intelligent analysis. So all signs point to Arthur being the awesome one šŸ˜‰

        Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s